#8 Power-to-X: the Possibilities of Electricity

Enormous potential lies in developing synthetic fuels. They could feed off of the carbon in the atmosphere, as well as the green electricity production we still need to invest in.

Liquid fuels are more condensed in energy than batteries.

Synthetic fuels are the missing link between renewable electricity and the sectors where electrification is most needed and yet most difficult. Through power-to-x (P2X) solutions, we can decarbonise transport segments like aviation and marine as well as energy intensive industries like steel production. The potential is enormous, and the possibilities endless. Synthetic fuels are the most prominent long-term solution for transferable energy storage, and they represent a probable pathway for displacing fossil fuels from the transport sector.

This happens through a power-to-x process, e.g. in which hydrogen is produced from water with renewable electricity through electrolysis. This hydrogen could then also be used in other processes, e.g. in the production of ammonia as fuel for the marine sector. The elements for synthetic fuels production are:

  • low-cost renewable electricity
  • hydrogen (H₂) created by the electrolysis of water
  • carbon dioxide (CO₂) extracted from the atmosphere or captured from industry

There are no limitations for the availability of carbon as a feedstock in the form of CO₂ and the distillation curve challenge can be avoided.

power to x

In a synthesis plant, carbon dioxide and hydrogen can be combined into hydrocarbon products like methane, gasoline, diesel, jet fuel or methanol. Production of synthetic ammonia is a similar process, except that the CO₂ is replaced by nitrogen (N2). Ammonia is an important raw material for fertilisers and a potential low-carbon fuel for shipping.

Synthetic fuels can be used in traditional combustion engines or gas turbines, and can also be blended gradually into the existing fossil fuel mix, displacing an ever-growing portion of the fossil energy.

One of the biggest advantages of synthetic fuels is the compatibility with existing liquid and gaseous fuel storage and distribution infrastructure.

This minimises the need for renewal of infrastructure and vehicle fleets, massively reducing the overall costs associated with decarbonisation. There are no limitations for the availability of carbon in the form of CO₂ and the distillation curve challenge (as explained in chapter #5) can be avoided. Power-to-x can achieve near carbon neutrality with enough renewable electricity and excess CO₂ as input. Production of synthetic fuels requires carbon capture technologies, and the CO₂ can be separated from large point sources, such as cement and steel production and pulp mills. CO₂ can also be separated from air through what is called Direct Air Capture (DAC) or from the sea. On the other hand, low CO₂ concentrations drive up the size of the equipment and the cost of each tonne of captured CO₂.

A comparison between hydrogen and hydrocarbon-based synthetic fuels show that the latter have properties which make them much more favourable as energy carriers. Using pure hydrogen as an energy carrier will be limited as a result of its poor volumetric energy density and its value chain shortcomings like distribution, storage and end-user applications. To conclude, we believe synthetic fuels will play a crucial role in the energy system of the future. The biggest bottleneck is – and will continue to be for the next decade – the availability of clean and cheap electricity. We must invest significantly in additional renewable electricity production and an accompanying electricity grid. It will also be important, and necessary, to research and develop solutions for lowering the production costs of synthetic fuels.

Feasibility study on synthetic fuels pilot plant

Use case: Feasibility study on synthetic fuels pilot plant

LUT University and a group of companies including St1, have started a feasibility study for a synthetic fuels pilot production plant. The intended industrial scale pilot facility is based on the Power-to-x concept, and the target is to produce carbon neutral fuels for transportation.

Q Power and St1 piloted synthetic fuel production

Use case: Q Power and St1 piloted synthetic fuel production

St1 and a renewable energy start-up Q Power launched in September a joint project for developing a novel way of making synthetic biomethane from carbon dioxide. In the pilot project, Q Power’s biological methanation technology utilised the carbon dioxide recovered from the production of waste-based ethanol at St1’s biorefinery.